On October 7, 2013 California Governor Jerry Brown signed a state bill prohibiting law-enforcement officials from detaining an individual on the basis of a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement hold after that person becomes eligible for release, unless he or she has been charged with or convicted of certain crimes, including violent felonies.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Deleted4yrs4Y
If the crime is violent deport them or if they have a history of petty theft.
@8MF33G54yrs4Y
No, u need to run a a background check instead oaf assuming that they are violent.siriosly, last week, a Mexican woman and chiled were kick out of their own car that they paid for fair and square with the money they earned, but the police said it was a stolen car because it LOOKED like a stolen car, but the license plates didn’t math.
@8LC9TY94yrs4Y
Only if it is a serious crime like death or robbery
Deleted4yrs4Y
If the crime was violent in any way
@9334YP33yrs3Y
Excepting the sheriff's department, law enforcement should be abolished and replaced by civil militias. Illegal immigrants should be deported at their own expense or receive the death penalty.
@9425J2G3yrs3Y
deport habitual offenders and violent crimes
Deleted4yrs4Y
Deleted4yrs4Y
Yes, after multiple arrests.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Depending on what the crime is and how many offenses.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Only after a certain amount of offenses.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Yes, after multiple offenses.
Deleted4yrs4Y
After a certain amount of offenses.
@8TP6QKS4yrs4Y
Yes, and we should execute all illegal immigrants who do not finance their own deportation
Deleted4yrs4Y
Only after multiple offenses.
Deleted4yrs4Y
@8LFQKGS4yrs4Y
i think they should be sent home instead of held in unclean centers
@8LNMGF74yrs4Y
No, deportation should only happen if their is a violent crime committed.
@heatherdvdprincess3yrs3Y
Yes, seport all illegal immigrants, after giving them access to a free online course or book on how to not be poor nor in danger where they're from.
@5BMX4XT3yrs3Y
Yes but only in the case of felonies.
@8Q6C4Y44yrs4Y
Yes, they broke the law and are here illegally, so they should be turned over to the immigration authorities
@8P6PWZP4yrs4Y
No, and victimless crimes shouldn't be considered crimes.
@925J4Q83yrs3Y
depends on the crime, but generally no
@8XHNZZH3yrs3Y
all depends on what you did ig
@6HDD83R4yrs4Y
Allow the states and U.S. territories to choose to officially become sanctuary states and territories, but the local and state law enforcement agencies should be authorized to arrest and/or deport illegal immigrants who are the following:
1. a member or associate member of the Freemasons and/or any other secret societies and organizations
2. a member or associate member of a criminal or terrorist organization
3. a member or associate member of a foreign leftist political party, all its formations, manifestations, associations, successors, paramilitary organizations, youth organizations,… Read more
@8PV49KX4yrs4Y
No, they should be transferred to services that help them become a legal immigrant, then prosecute them for their crime
@8WKBXX73yrs3Y
for immigrants that are non-violent should be allowed to stay the shouldn't be deported for minor(small) issues
@92YHQCV3yrs3Y
No, but only if they are convicted of a violent crime, because too many non-violent immigrants are being deported
@8SCSBS64yrs4Y
no, they deserve to get educated.
@8QT5JBT4yrs4Y
they should be dealt with correctly but maybe not deported
@8H4DF7B4yrs4Y
No, unless they refuse to complete the process to make up for coming here illegally through community service, jail time, paying a fee, jury duty, or military service AND completing the class to become a citizen.
@IINXMP4yrs4Y
Yes, but limit the border zone to five to ten miles.
@IINXMP4yrs4Y
No, and limit the border zone to five to ten miles.
@8TVYZQL4yrs4Y
No, as long as they undergo consequences for their minor crimes and pay there taxes.
@3M775G24yrs4Y
Yes, but create a simple path to citizenship for immigrants with no criminal record.
@78S5M874yrs4Y
Only if they were not granted citizenship
@6NLNK8C4yrs4Y
No, not for one offense, but there should be a points system to transfer repeat offenders to immigration.
@7NMLC8N4yrs4Y
No, unless the crime is violent in nature. Rather, a process for the immigrant to obtain citizenship should be initialized.
@82K4BM44yrs4Y
Yes, but then they should be allowed to request entry legally
@8BVCB3Y4yrs4Y
The term "minor crimes" is too vague as opposed to the learn more section. That aside, major crimes such as violence felonies should result in a being turned over to federal immigration authorities. Minor crimes should be taken into consideration after a certain accumulated amount.
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
No, only if they are charged with or convicted of a violent felony
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
No, only if they are convicted of a violent felony
@8CYG8KL4yrs4Y
No, they should get the same sentence as an American.
@8GR8N5C4yrs4Y
No, only if they have convicted a violent crime that was not self-defense
@8L7L9FZ4yrs4Y
They need to get under control, we need to detain and deport any illegal immigrants, but not separate anyone from their parents.
@8LFXCNC4yrs4Y
let them serve time if guilty
@8LBRM8F4yrs4Y
Unless there is previous knowledge of violent crime, or criminal history and are wanted by the authorities in their own country, they should not be handed over to the Federal Immigration Authorities.
@8LMWBN44yrs4Y
if its a small accident then no but if its serious then yes
@8LSVCGK4yrs4Y
Yes, It depends on the severity of the crime
@8M2BGYV4yrs4Y
No, and make it easier to grant them citizenship
@8M4S9XJ4yrs4Y
no, only when convicted for manager crimes like breaking and entering or violent crimes
@8MF8XFJ4yrs4Y
Yes, but only once the immigration system is made less punitive.
@8NY4BWF4yrs4Y
Again this is a loaded question. It depends on too many factors.. where do we draw the line and how much does it cost us to detain and deport. Perhaps have them do community service and set guidelines by which they can stay and get on the path for residency. Perhaps the path requires a lot of steps and is difficult to achieve without working diligently to do so. There has to be more discussion around what we as a country hope to achieve as well as how do we achieve it.
@8PGXGG64yrs4Y
Yes they entered the country illegally but the should not be deported only held until they complete their immigration process legally
@TogetherinSoli14yrs4Y
Yes, but only if they are convicted of a violent, or drug-related crime
@8QKJ7R94yrs4Y
Yes, all illegal immigrants should be turned over to federal authorities and deported if they do not leave or become citizens within a reasonable amount of time after being discovered
@8T9X24H4yrs4Y
Yes, but not if the detainee was the person who called the police.
@8TKFNNS4yrs4Y
Yes Only if they have a real documented history of crime from the country they live in before they came to the united states of America other than that they should mostly be deported unless they enter legally.
@8V5PJ3X4yrs4Y
*in order to create a fluid system prepared to take on such a heavy workload, flush the system out to make reconfiguration a lot easier
@8W8WFZ53yrs3Y
It depends on the type of crime, but there should be a background check to make sure it hasn’t happened before. If they do it more than once, they should be sentenced to prison or deported.
@8WP5BCC3yrs3Y
No they shouldn't get sent federally but if they robbed a bank I think they should serve the time of a normal citizen.
@8WNLM9C3yrs3Y
Everyone legal or not should be taught about our most basic laws and rules and then if an illegal immigrant has been told the laws and still proceeds to commit a violent crime, then they should be deported.
@8WQT4JC3yrs3Y
Yes, illegal immigrants do not have constitutional rights because they are not U.S. citizens, but legal immigrants should be treated the same as any other Americans
@8WZKS5D3yrs3Y
Illegal immigrants who already reside here should be treated the same as other residents. Future illegal immigrants should be turned over to federal immigration authorities and deported.
@8XHHWJ23yrs3Y
well if they looked you up and they see you came here ilegally
@8XJYDR33yrs3Y
Yes, if they have a violent criminal record
@8XZ2SSR3yrs3Y
Yes, but give them the option to apply for citizenship as long as they have not been convicted of a violent crime
@93GLTS33yrs3Y
Yes, but they shouldn't be put in a state in which they could be deported.
@93GLTSM3yrs3Y
Yes, but they shouldn't be treated with harsh punishment for it.
Join in on more popular conversations.